Score: 9

"This is hilarious"

submission: Charlie the Unicorn 2

date: April 15, 2008

This is really one of the most hilarious things on newgrounds, and I am lucky that it was posted on Newgrounds before it was posted on Youtube. The animation is rather simple but it suits the plot and story line and overall style of the movie very well. The voices were really great, well, besides Charlie's. His voice was by far different and better in the first part if I remember correctly.

I love how they go through all of this crap just to steal something from Charlie. Very nicely made, I really like the effects. Especially the vortex and the banana amulet beam.

All in all this is a great movie, the only major complaint would be Charlie's weird voice.

Score: 9

"This is sad"

submission: Home Movies: FFS

date: April 15, 2008

This is so much better than your Zelda movie. It's really sad that this one gets left alone with 11 reviews and not even 2000 views while your Zelda movie gets a couple of 100 views every day. This proves, once again, that Newgrounds is about fan service, but once you do fan service only people will grow tired of it. Hard to survive on here.

Almost the same art style than before but this time it suits the people better. I am sorry for suggesting you to do something more original without checking out your other flash movies first. This is really good and it should have a score by far higher than this one.

Score: 6

"Seems to be the same stuff"

submission: Madness Inundation

date: April 15, 2008

All of your Madness movies seem to be the same stuff over and over again with a minor improvement of graphics and animation. It looks like it's tweened, yet, I know it's not. Your frame by frame skills, as I saw on your Project I.V. flash are really good, you've also proven that in the episode of Madness where the clown turns into a beast. The fire was fairly well animated. I enjoyed madness when it partly followed a story line. Now it's basically this: Hunt Clown, hunt Jesus, get almost killed, end of the episode. Then the new episode starts with the Madness main character arising from the dead or unconsciousness and start beating up people again.

Maybe start to come up with a great plot twist or something alike for a change? Or maybe make a sequel to Project I.V, I would really love to see one of these.

Score: 2

"And here is another episode of SMBZ"

submission: Super Mario bros Z ep 6

date: April 15, 2008

And as expected, nothing has changed. You still are using the exact same sprites and the same animation techniques. The same things are happening over in over again so the plot isn't really advancing here. The effects are nice as always and the movie is pretty long for a flash, I give you that, but the rest of the movie is just tweened or stolen. Stolen, because it's just ripped images but that is just my opinion. Others might think that taking things and giving credit without asking the owners is no stealing, but I think it qualifies as that.

The animation was besides the effects rather poorly done and so was, as I said already, the plot. You are probably a very talented artist and some original work for once wouldn't hurt you, I am sure of that.

I know that making sprite movies and getting tons of attention and money for them makes you happy and satisfied, but maybe you should try to satisfy audience with a brain that are above the age of thirteen. You, Alvin Earthworm, are going the way of Legendary Frog and I tell you, it's probably not the way you are wanting to take. Look at Legendary Frog now, nobody really likes him or his flashes anymore and if you keep up the fan service only people will start to get tired of it really fast.

Score: 3

"Animation and art..?"

submission: Zelda: Heart for the Hero

date: April 15, 2008

First off, I do get the joke, I don't like Zelda though. This movie builds up completely on the Zelda games, there is no creativity in the jokes whatsoever. The art in this movie is really not that good because it's very edgy and there is no shading on the characters. The animation at the end was really nice, where Link is slashing the store keeper but besides that it seemed all to be tweened up and down, back and forth, left and right.

The voice acting of the store keeper was very quiet compared to the ripped Link sound clips. The background art was ok but that doesn't really make up the rest of the movie.

I would appreciate something more original, something that isn't entirely based up on a video game.

Score: 3

"Well made, I guess"

submission: Awesome Video Games Ep29

date: April 14, 2008

The video in this submission was funny, I liked it. The over hyped reaction about something boring is always nice. I've got one complaint though, this website is Newgrounds, a website for animations. This is not youtube and I don't think that Newgrounds wants to become something similar to youtube either. I don't know why this is on frontpage, cause it has nothing to do with flash at all but I'll give you 3 stars for entertainment anyways.

Score: 10

"Very artistic"

submission: Captain Blackjack

date: April 14, 2008

I really liked the animation style. The voice acting was great, the animation overall was smooth and nicely made. I couldn't stop laughing well done.

The waves at the beginning of the movie looked a little off but besides that, it was beautiful. I barely see flashes with an artistic merit such as this one. The green, red and blue outlines of the characters gave the whole flash a very nice touch.

The voice acting was great, it couldn't have been better. It fit to the situation very well.

Incredible work, overall. This is one of the few flashes that prove that quantity does not surpass quality in any way.

Score: 2

"Lame and badly made"

submission: Super Smash bros ST 5

date: April 14, 2008

90% of the flash were premade sprites, sprites that you have used, probably without even asking for permission. The movie was really boring and slow paced most of the time, the fight looked like a huge tweenfest. When the characters jumped, they were in their idle position floating up into the air, sonic was the only character who had some kind of jumping animation. The Giga Bowser, which I assume you drew on your own, looked extremely horrible. I'm not sure if it was actually the drawing that looked horrible or if it was the fact that you put a stupid inner glow filter in it, a filter that wasn't used at all. You should try to animate and draw the next part of the series all by yourself, the score would be by far better. I advice you to do something more original though. You've got this ridiculously high score because it's Super Smash Bros. Brawl and Nintendo/Sega related.

I really liked the effects of the movie though. Was the movie completely made in flash or did you use After Effects or Photoshop for the electricity animations for example? It looked like After Effects.

One star for quantity, it's not worth a lot and one star for the effects that didn't really save the movie either.

Now this is just my opinion, I hope you aren't as much of an asshole as the guy who made the Tutorial Collab '08 and respond with something like "You're picky".

Score: 3

"It's ok"

submission: Duel of the Ages

date: April 14, 2008

It's pretty bad but compared to your other really bad submissions it seems like you have actually tried to create something nice this time. You should keep up the effort, the "CAI" series don't have a bright future, you should entirely stop with that and with the other spam, too. I don't know why people are spamming Newgrounds with that stuff anyways. Spam is only fun as long as you get angry reviews and that doesn't happen on your spam anymore.

Score: 6

"The game wasn't too good"

submission: Thing-Thing 4

date: April 14, 2008

The game was decently coded but the art and animation wasn't too convincing. The gameplay got boring after a while seeing as the game is somewhat slow paced. The art reminds of the Madness series a lot but I think that's what you were aiming for because the gameplay is similar also.

It was entertaining for about 2 rooms, for me at least. The game itself was as I said decently coded, so 5 stars for that but the animation, gameplay and art is off.